By Katie Zeng (*)
管他熙熙攘攘眼光道,我非要一条独木桥走到黑. (Roughly: Let the crowds and their stares say what they will. I’ll walk this single-plank bridge to the end.) – The Untamed
The Chinese drama The Untamed drew in billions of views and turned Xiao Zhan and Wang Yibo into international stars. Adapted from a danmei (boy love), this censored love story paints a tale of morality and how people are not simply black or white, good or evil. Since then, Chinamaxxing, the online trend of embracing Chinese culture, has taken over the internet. As crisis after crisis erodes Americans’ faith in their own institutions, China’s model, which rests on delivering for its people and removing threats to stability quickly, can look attractive.
Americans’ picture of China swings between dystopia and utopia, and neither explains how the system works or how people live inside it. Flatten China into simply evil, and we lose sight of both people and the machinery influencing us. China’s pitch works best when Americans see the choice as good versus evil, and Washington’s own rhetoric helps it along. Countering propaganda starts with recognizing that no country fits a single label.
The Great Firewall. To many Americans, the Great Firewall, which blocks foreign sites like Google, YouTube and Netflix, seems dystopian. A friend of mine who grew up in China and is studying in the United States, told me otherwise: “Everyone in China uses a VPN and the government knows that.” VPNs, or Virtual Private Networks, allow users to mask their IP address and physical location, allowing those in China to access sites otherwise blocked. While many members of the informed public use VPNs, it is still considered a crime in China. But the police don’t aggressively go after these acts. Michael Cunningham, a senior fellow at the Stimson Center, explained why. The state cares less about policing every individual than about what spreads inside China.“They have really strict laws against spreading rumors, but enforcement often depends on how widely the information was shared. No harm is done if it isn’t widely shared.” The firewall’s real target is perception, not access.
In 2020, this was tested when the fanfiction site Archive of Our Own (AO3) was taken down after fans of actor Xiao Zhan mass reported of a fanfic about their favorite actor, claiming it would damage his reputation. The site had long been antithetical to the goal of controlling narratives; what doomed it was the fic’s reach. Various groups formed coalitions to boycott Xiao Zhan, ultimately resulting in the actor losing brand deals and being blacklisted. Although he has since resumed his activities, many of his projects have been promotional projects that celebrate the government’s actions, including being the face of Chongqing’s Anti-Fraud Campaign and performing patriotic tracks for cultural programs. Cunningham sees the logic: “The CCP has a very nuanced view of its strengths and weaknesses. They will control the risks and exploit the opportunities.” To this day, AO3 remains blocked. Xiao Zhan came out relatively unscathed, but others, like Zheng Shuang and Zhang Zhehan, have virtually lost their careers in China.
The Influencers. Creators like misseatinggood have gathered hundreds of thousands of followers with videos arguing that life in China beats life in the United States. But what explains the popularity of these Chinese influencers in the US? Cunningham points to talent first: “In a country of 1.4 billion people, if you want to be a star and deal with censorship, you have to be a master of your craft.” The second draw is American discontent. With high costs of living, rising unemployment, and democratic structures at home feeling less reliable, and a steady diet of stories about how miserable life in China must be, a cheerful counter-voice lands hard and erodes trust in the story.
China’s appeal is real. Cunningham, who lived in China for several years, recalls standing in Shanghai “thinking about how many people live in the high-rise apartment buildings as far as the eye can see and how much wealth there is in the area.” But an appeal that depends on controlling every plank of the bridge is brittle, and an American enthusiasm born of grievance at home says more about us than about China.
My friend put it best: “There’re some people who would really like the system but a lot of people like individualism. It varies by person…the more you see it, China is not that different.” Like the characters in The Untamed, the countries in our world are not black and white. To feed into that idea of good or evil is to fall into the trap that propaganda and particularly authoritarian influences have on our perceptions about the world we live in and the countries that we call home.
(*) Katie Zeng is currently pursuing a Master’s degree in Democracy and Governance at Georgetown University, with a previous Bachelor degree in Political Science and International Affairs from Wake Forest University.
References
Bachulska, Alicja. “Chinamaxxing: Beijing’s New Source of Soft Power.” European Council on Foreign Relations, April 23, 2026. https://ecfr.eu/article/chinamaxxing-beijings-new-source-of-soft-power/
Interview with Michael Cunningham, senior fellow, Stimson Center: [10/05/26].
Interview with Chinese friend: [9/26/26].
文汇报 (Wenhui Daily). “时隔两年,《陈情令》播放量破95亿” (“Two Years Later, The Untamed Tops 9.5 Billion Views”). NetEase (163.com), June 24, 2021. https://m.163.com/dy/article/GD9FRQ5805506BEH.html
Feng, Emily. “China Blocks Website After Complaints About Fan Fiction Story On A Celebrity.” NPR (All Things Considered), October 28, 2020. https://www.npr.org/2020/10/28/928805796/china-blocks-website-after-complaints-about-fan-fiction-story-on-a-celebrity
Sg, Suzanne. “Actress Zheng Shuang loses fans and endorsement deals over surrogacy scandal.” The Straits Times, January 21, 2020. https://www.straitstimes.com/life/entertainment/actress-zheng-shuang-loses-fans-and-endorsement-deals-over-surrogacy-scandal
文汇报 (Wenhui Daily). “时隔两年,《陈情令》播放量破95亿” (“Two Years Later, The Untamed Tops 9.5 Billion Views”). NetEase (163.com), June 24, 2021. https://m.163.com/dy/article/GD9FRQ5805506BEH.html
1000snow. “The Crucifixion of Zhang Zhehan in the Age of Misinformation.” Medium, August 22, 2021. https://medium.com/@1000snow/the-crucifixion-of-zhang-zhehan-in-the-age-of-misinformation-5b08b0d06e40




